Oakland Police Bar Student Journalists from Press Conference

UPDATE: In a shocking incident, the Oakland Police Department (OPD) barred student journalist Nelzy Gonzalez-Zaragoza from a press conference held on November 14, 2025, regarding the tragic death of beloved Laney College coach John Beam, who was fatally shot on campus just a day earlier. This unprecedented action raises serious questions about press freedom and access to critical information.

The incident unfolded moments before the scheduled media event when OPD officials insisted that Gonzalez-Zaragoza, an associate editor for the Peralta Citizen, had not secured a police-issued press credential. This controversial policy has sparked outrage among journalists and First Amendment advocates, who claim it obstructs the press’s ability to inform the public on significant community issues.

“This is a high-profile case, but I felt comfortable going in there… it’s not fair that any reporter was kicked out,” Gonzalez-Zaragoza stated, expressing her frustration. She was not alone; journalists from The Oaklandside and the San Francisco Chronicle also faced barriers, with some only allowed entry after hastily applying for credentials.

“OPD interfered with journalists’ ability to do their jobs for no reason,” wrote the First Amendment Coalition in a letter to police officials and Mayor Barbara Lee.

The OPD maintains that the press credential policy is a necessary security measure, aimed at ensuring safety during media events. However, critics argue that the restriction serves only to undermine journalistic independence and limit access to vital news sources, especially in a community mourning the loss of a local hero.

Assistant Chief James Beere, appointed as interim police chief, defended the policy, stating, “Knowing the identity of journalists accessing non-public areas within the Police Administration Building is vital for everyone’s safety.” His remarks, however, have done little to assuage the growing discontent among media representatives.

“There were no security threats, space limitations, or other lawful justifications to exclude or erect barriers to access,” the First Amendment advocates countered, calling for an immediate end to the restrictive policy. They highlighted that similar media events at Oakland City Hall and the Alameda County District Attorney’s Office do not require such credentials.

Gonzalez-Zaragoza and her fellow reporters were eager to cover the story surrounding Beam’s death, a tragedy that has resonated deeply within the community. The legendary coach gained fame through Netflix’s “Last Chance U,” and his sudden loss has left many searching for answers.

As the day progressed, Gonzalez-Zaragoza quickly shifted her focus to other reporting avenues despite the setback. “We went to work right away,” she explained, determined to keep the community informed with updates and insights surrounding the tragic events at Laney College.

The incident has ignited a larger debate about press access and the implications of police control over media coverage. While OPD insists their measures are for safety, journalists argue that such actions hinder their fundamental role in society. The call for revisiting the policy has never been more critical, given the pressing need for transparent communication in times of crisis.

As developments unfold, the community and media alike will be watching closely for any changes to the OPD’s approach. This incident is a stark reminder of the ongoing struggle for press freedom, especially in the face of significant local tragedies. The push for accountability and access continues, underscoring the essential role of journalism in our communities.