Urgent: ‘Romy & Michele’ Musical Bombs at Stage 42, Critics React

UPDATE: The much-anticipated stage adaptation of the 1997 cult classic “Romy and Michele’s High School Reunion” has opened at Stage 42 in New York City, and early reviews are devastating. Critics are describing the production as a dismal failure, lacking the charm and humor of its film predecessor.

The musical, which stars Broadway veterans Laura Bell Bundy and Kara Lindsay, has been dubbed “a clunker” by critics, drawing parallels to the discomfort of attending a high school reunion where everyone seems to have outdone you. With ticket prices exceeding $100, many are questioning whether this show is worth the expense.

Critics are expressing concern that the production, first seen in Seattle in 2017, fails to capture the anarchic silliness and vibrant spirit of the beloved movie. As one critic put it, “This new Off-Broadway attraction is about as much fun as watching ‘Pretty Woman’ 36 times.”

The plot follows the titular characters, originally portrayed by Mira Sorvino and Lisa Kudrow, as they navigate the awkwardness of their high school reunion by fabricating successful identities. However, the musical’s attempts to recreate the film’s chemistry fall flat, as critics note that Bundy and Lindsay struggle to deliver laughs or emotional depth.

The score, crafted by Gwendolyn Sanford and Brandon Jay, lacks the nostalgic flavor of the late 1990s, leaving audiences with generic Broadway pop instead of catchy hits. Critics argue that this musical fails to evoke the laughter and connection that the film did, with visuals and staging that do not land effectively.

A key issue highlighted is the script’s adherence to the original movie, which limits the stars’ ability to showcase their unique talents. As noted by critics, the production resembles a “sinkhole,” stifling creativity and originality among the cast, which includes DeMarius R. Copes in a minor role.

The production’s reliance on a cheesy, all-digital set has also drawn criticism, as it attempts visual jokes that do not resonate with audiences. Director Kristin Hanggi, known for her work on “Rock of Ages,” has been criticized for failing to bring the same energy to this adaptation.

The overwhelming consensus among critics is clear: “Romy & Michele The Musical” may be a painful experience, akin to an actual high school reunion. With its lack of comedic moments and emotional engagement, it appears that this adaptation has missed the mark entirely.

As the show faces backlash, audiences are left wondering what will happen next. Will there be significant changes to salvage this production, or will it fade quickly into obscurity? The industry is watching closely as reactions to this high-profile flop continue to unfold.

Stay tuned for more updates on this developing story as its impact on the Off-Broadway scene becomes clearer.