MLB Bold Predictions Graded: A’s, Yankees, and More Face Reality

UPDATE: The MLB season predictions for 2025 have been graded, revealing surprising successes and dismal failures across all 30 teams. As fans digest the outcomes, the focus shifts to what these results mean for the upcoming 2026 season.

With predictions ranging from A+ to F, the grading offers insights into player performances and team dynamics. For example, the Pittsburgh Pirates saw Paul Skenes not only win the Cy Young Award but also achieve the best season for a Pirates starter since 1920, earning an impressive grade of A+. This sets high expectations for 2026, where Skenes could aim for even greater heights.

In stark contrast, the New York Yankees faced a harsh reality check. Despite predictions of a losing season, the Yankees exceeded expectations, finishing with 94 wins. Their performance earns them a dismal grade of F, leaving fans to wonder how they can build on this success moving forward.

The Seattle Mariners also shined, with Bryan Woo emerging as the top starter and finishing fifth in Cy Young voting, receiving another A+. Looking ahead, the Mariners hope for continued success as they chase their first World Series appearance.

On the flip side, the Miami Marlins struggled early in the season and failed to trade Sandy Alcantara, who had a rough start, resulting in a grade of D+. Their future remains uncertain as they look to bounce back in 2026.

The Chicago White Sox also faced a tough season, finishing with 102 losses and earning a grade of D+. The team must regroup as they aim to improve their performance next year.

As the 2026 season approaches, fans and analysts alike will be closely watching how these teams adjust and respond to their 2025 outcomes. The grading of predictions not only sheds light on individual player performances but also highlights the unpredictable nature of the game.

With excitement building, fans are encouraged to share these developments and discuss their implications for their favorite teams. The landscape of MLB continues to shift, and every prediction matters as teams prepare for the next chapter.