8 Must-Play Mystery Games for Halloween 2025: Get Ready Now!

UPDATE: As Halloween approaches, gamers are urged to explore the thrilling world of mystery games instead of traditional horror titles. With just days left until October 31, 2025, the gaming community is buzzing with excitement over these highly recommended titles that offer suspense without the jump scares.

Mystery games deliver immersive narratives and psychological intrigue, perfect for those who prefer a more cerebral experience. Here are 8 compelling mystery games to dive into this Halloween:

1. What Remains of Edith Finch (2017)
This critically acclaimed title invites players to explore the tragic tales of a cursed family. Each story is uniquely crafted, blending the themes of death and beauty seamlessly. As you navigate the hauntingly designed house, you’ll discover the unsettling history that lingers within, making it a profound choice for Halloween gaming.

2. Dredge (2023)
Described as “cozy horror,” Dredge combines fishing mechanics with Lovecraftian elements. Players will find themselves caught in a web of mysterious occurrences while fishing in a foggy archipelago. This title offers a relaxing start that quickly escalates into a gripping encounter with the unknown, ensuring players remain on the edge of their seats.

3. Gone Home (2013)
Set in a creaky old manor during a thunderstorm, Gone Home presents an engaging narrative that uncovers the fate of a missing family. The emotional depth and powerful storytelling provide a moving experience, making it a staple for any Halloween gaming list.

4. The Sinking City Remastered (2025)
Immerse yourself in this open-world detective game where players unravel mysteries in a city steeped in Lovecraftian lore. As you navigate Oakmont, you’ll confront conspiracies and secrets that will keep your heart racing without traditional horror scares.

5. House of Ashes (2021)
Part of the Dark Pictures Anthology, this title takes players through a story set during the Iraq War. The narrative’s moral complexities and mythological themes create an atmosphere of suspense, making it ideal for gamers seeking mystery over horror.

6. Return of the Obra Dinn (2018)
In this unique adventure, players assume the role of an insurance investigator examining a ghost ship filled with mysteries. The game’s distinct art style and innovative mechanics will captivate players, proving that sometimes mystery can be more unsettling than horror.

7. Hell is Us (2025)
This title takes players deep into a war-torn fictional country, challenging them to confront both external conflicts and internal demons. The mysterious plot and immersive gameplay make it a standout choice for those seeking a thought-provoking gaming experience this Halloween.

8. The Wolf Among Us (2013)
Step into the shoes of Bigby Wolf, the sheriff of Fabletown, in this episodic adventure. With its noir atmosphere and rich storytelling, this game captivates players as they navigate a world where fairy tales intertwine with gritty reality.

As gamers prepare for Halloween, these mystery titles offer an engaging alternative to horror games, focusing on story, atmosphere, and psychological depth. With Halloween just around the corner, it’s time to light a candle, plug in your headphones, and let these mysteries pull you under. Get ready for an unforgettable gaming experience this October!