Judge Rules Against Ex-San Leandro Officer in Shooting Case

UPDATE: A judge has just denied a motion to dismiss the trial against former San Leandro police officer Jason Fletcher, who is accused of fatally shooting Steven Taylor at a Walmart in 2020. The ruling, delivered on Friday at the Alameda County Superior Court, marks a pivotal moment in the long-fought legal battle for Taylor’s family.

Family members gathered outside the courthouse, visibly emotional, as they expressed their relief and hope following the judge’s decision. Addie Kitchen, Taylor’s grandmother, stated, “Five years and 7 months, we have been fighting just to get to this point.” Kitchen had previously submitted a letter urging the judge to consider their family’s plight, highlighting numerous delays in the legal process.

The courtroom tension was palpable as Kitchen remarked on the importance of the case going to a jury, saying, “Let the jury make a decision.” Taylor was shot after being suspected of shoplifting at the Walmart, sparking outrage and demands for justice from both the family and community advocates.

Critics, including Cat Brooks, Executive Director of the Anti-Police Terror Project, have condemned the district attorney, Nancy O’Malley, for her handling of the case. Brooks criticized O’Malley for previously never charging a police officer during her tenure, emphasizing the urgent need for accountability. “There is a reason for that,” Brooks said, pointing out that Fletcher had alternatives to using deadly force, including de-escalation tactics.

The tragic incident unfolded when police released cellphone video showing Fletcher attempting to disarm Taylor, who was reportedly swinging a baseball bat. After Taylor refused to comply, he was Tased, leading to Fletcher firing his weapon and being charged with manslaughter for using excessive force.

The family has been vocal about Taylor’s struggles with mental health issues, which the San Leandro Police Department was aware of prior to the incident. Taylor’s mother, Sharon Taylor, expressed her gratitude that the charges were not dismissed, stating, “I’m grateful that this wasn’t dismissed. Pushed under the rug.”

With the trial set to proceed, the community watches closely, hoping for a resolution that brings justice to Taylor’s family. Fletcher had previously sought to have the trial moved out of Alameda County, but that request was denied. The case will now move forward, with many questioning what the jury will ultimately decide.

As the situation develops, the family and supporters remain steadfast in their pursuit of justice, underscoring the critical need for accountability in law enforcement. The outcome of this high-profile case could have lasting implications for police conduct and community relations.

Stay tuned for updates as this urgent story unfolds.